Florida Pier : writings and about       /       jmcvey.net

The Conservation of Revolutions
“The Gentler View,” Harper’s Weekly (September 17, 1910) : 21
U Michigan copy/scan (via hathitrust) : link
archive.org : link
 

      An epoch-making event very frequently disappoints by the resemblance between matters as they were before and matters as they are after its occurrence. A complete and radical change is often so difficult to discern as to dishearten considerably the person changed, while any one not intimately concerned might be pardoned for doubting the existence of any change whatsoever. The belief that life could be greatly bettered is the first premise on which we live, so that our interest in a new philosophy, particularly an actively constructive one, is so ready that we are apt to prepare for a reading of it by denying all merit to our present mode of life and opening the volume anxious to change in accordance with its precepts down to the smallest details of our daily routine. We enthusiastically welcome the author’s sweeping away of what we have unwillingly accepted before as fundamental truths. He substitutes adaptations that go to our empty heads and make them flighty with anticipation. We feel that from now on all is to be different, and rush ahead We feel that from now on all is to be different, and rush ahead to his carefully proven theory that society acts from mistaken impulses, staggers under wrong laws, and frustrates childishly its better aims. We see clearly how bungled and blind our every move has been, and to usher in the new epoch, to make its newness keenly felt, we are planning subconsciously, even while reading, to lead a life wherein every second shall be well considered and deeply planned, where everything shall have a meaning, and by its outward aspect exhibit clearly how opposite its present meaning is from its old.
      Then toward the end of the book, when our outlook on life has been refurbished to the point of giddy exaltation, the philosopher who has berated our every act, until we feel confident he would not have us continue in the old ruts another day, says, with a calm that grieves and comes near to prostrating us, that, owing to the slowness with which humanity develops, and other reasons — economic, prehistoric ones are touched on vaguely and discouragingly — we must do just as we have always done, though from the entirely different point of view with which he has provided us. We must marry, bring up our children, vote, go to church, steer the cantankerous boat of family life, seemingly as we did before, though each act is now the result of reasoning so deep and far reaching that it ought to give us more comfort than it does.
      On reaching the end of such a book — Wells’s First and Last Things is an example stirring in its appeal, and not without its humorous, human conclusion that “livin’ is real complicated and we just got’er do our best” (the quotatation is not from Mr. Wells) “livin’ is real complicated and we just got’er do our best” (the quotatation is not from Mr. Wells) — one half of us feels armed with a weapon strong and bright enough to last to the end, and the other half is so disappointed that in its limp woe it can just utter a reproachful “Traitor,” but half directed at the author. To change completely would be comparatively easy, the wearing of a meaningful habit reminding one constantly for what it stood, constantly pushing a possibly weak spirit to loyalty for The Idea by a staunchness in wearing the robe expressing it. But to compromise, to go to no glaring extreme — there is something peculiarly supporting in an extreme which may account for the many strong extremists we have about — it requires character. To lead a normal life, holding all the while a new and clearly formed idea of life’s meaning, and what makes normality advantageous, requires an understanding of one’s adopted philosophy, so thorough as to make an insistence on minor points unnecessary. This after we had pinned all our faith on our ability to remember those very minor points, even when the reason for them became blurred. It has its pathos.
      The straight and narrow way of which we used to hear so much is none other than the middle course advised by conservation[ist]s, worded differently by modern teachers, but strangely like. Abstinence is as bad as indulgence, and indulgence is not a whit worse than abstinence. Our recently discovered philosopher who we thought was going to make life such plain sailing has deserted us, led us up to bypaths we never suspected, and then dumped us down, on that spot we would least willingly have found ourselves in, the middle way, the ticklish channel of ever-changing, far-reaching right and wrong. Nothing is fixed, nothing can lead you through a homely act with honor, but your conception of life’s meaning; nothing is made good or bad but by that, nothing is as simple as revolution seems, nothing more natural than our supine relief in its easy radicalism. Our recently discovered philosopher who we thought was going to make life such plain sailing has deserted us, led us up to bypaths we never suspected, and then dumped us down, on that spot we would least willingly have found ourselves in, the middle way, the ticklish channel of ever-changing, far-reaching right and wrong. To have all one’s definite beliefs qualified by kindliness or justice, to push one’s own prejudices from under one, and, having nothing but ignorance with which to fill the gap, to leave it empty and continue standing as straight as though the vacancy were comfortably filled, this is a problem resembling our old one, and is not the result expected from the perusing of a philosopher and friend. It is not a result at all. It is a predicament, and reminds us cruelly of the old Italian scientists who drew up a solemn paper saying in words of much legal quaintness, which are unfortunately not at hand to be quoted, that after many years their society could truthfully say that much valuable investigation had been carried on earnestly, with results of interest to all and honorable to those most concerned. Now that the fiftieth anniversary had arrived, they took an accounting of all they had done, and announced to their fellow townsmen and all others interested that they had made no definite discoveries whatsoever, but felt fully justified in and had every intention of continuing their work on the lines originally chosen.
 

20261103