Florida Pier : writings and about / jmcvey.net
Flowers
“The Gentler View,” Harper’s Weekly (November 2, 1912) : 21
Purdue copy/scan (via hathitrust) : link
U Chicago copy/scan (hathitrust, via archive.org) : link
archive.org : link
Gardening is such a public, exposed sort of hobby to pursue. Any one coming into the garden can see precisely what you are at. All know the exact extent of your demands and contentment. They have your measure so irretrievably. The ignominies connected with gardening are so many. One is almost always dirty and one is sometimes wildly disheveled. Invariably one is found huddled in some earthy corner and the whole thing lacks dignity and mystery. People are so apt to walk by in a superior way with immaculate hands and tidy clothes, and they remark, coldly, “What are you doing, grubbing there?”
You mutter, meekly, “I’m not grubbing.”
They continue, standing the while in a statuesque pose, “But what are you doing?”
With a blend of embarrassment and anger you explain, “Dibbling bulbs.” They look you in the eye and, try as you will, you cannot return their gaze. Dibbling bulbs does not seem a justifiable occupation for an adult of intelligence. It has a very foolish sound.
They say, “I suppose you know you have been at it for three solid hours.”
You blush and look intently at the earth, and finally they pass on, pausing at a little distance to pluck a late-blooming rose. a late-blooming rose... It has elegance, infinitely more than dibbling bulbs.You realize keenly that that is the way a lady should behave in a garden. It has elegance, infinitely more than dibbling bulbs. It wins respect, whereas gardening does not. (Exploding for the countless time that absurd fallacy about the dignity of labor and the shamefulness of leisure.) How can one ever reprimand one’s children again for being dirty or making mud pies in the flower borders when, as far as they can see, you are indulging yourself in that precise direction? Callers sometimes are permitted to stray into the garden, and they find you with an agricultural crick in your back, unfit to shake hands.
They exclaim, “How very interesting gardening must be!” You know they do not mean it and are bored when you explain that, though the border looks very hopeless now, it is expected to be surprisingly beautiful next May. They say, “You do not mind waiting so long for your results?” and you confess that you do not, and, what is more, you are not depressed at the prospect of discovering in May that you have made a mistake and rectifying it the April after. You are painfully conscious that your confession shows a simple, almost rudimentary mind. Your satisfaction and enthusiasm for your absurd grubbing beams out of your face. There is not a possibility of concealment. Even the fact that a great many famous people have sunk to the same level of feeble-mindedness does not rob you of your dislike of being caught at it by superior folk who have never felt the same temptation and succumbed to it with the same abandon.
Even the gardener, who might be expected to feel differently, has a way of conducting his visiting fellow-gardeners by paths that do not pass the plot where you are working Even the gardener, who might be expected to feel differently, has a way of conducting his visiting fellow-gardeners by paths that do not pass the plot where you are working, and you have an idea that it is not from delicacy, but from a feeling that a woman gardener is like a woman drunk, so much worse than a man in the same condition.
No one else who rides a hobby is exposed to the same indignities. Another person may take a cab and go off to a shop where she has heard there is a teapot of special make. She buys it, brings it home, and adds it to her collection, and every point of the proceeding is highly respectable. Butterfly-hunters must look a little foolish at times, but even they have the advantage of committing their follies in the heart of Brazil and other distant places. Most hobbies confer the distinction of being an expert upon their followers, but so few people can be genuine experts when their subject is nature. One plants an unlikely-looking stick because one thinks it will grow, but then of course it may not. It did last year, but it may not this and it has very little feeling for a precedence established. Certain seeds should have pink blooms, but they are just as likely to have purple. Climbing roses do not always climb and dwarf roses sometimes do. One just humbly hopes that one’s plans may be slightly followed, but knows that they probably will not.
That may be the reason why a gardener cannot swagger as impressively about his hobby as another hobbyist can. A teapot remains a teapot, and unless one is very inexperienced it remains the same teapot as when it was bought. But when friends come to see one’s garden one does not explain and expatiate and appear tremendously knowing. One just trails along after the others and thinks how differently one intended it to be. The things that are admired happen by accident. The things one expected to startle the eye never came off at all, and one’s principal emotion is one of gratitude because the flowers have to maintain a meek silence and can never tell how completely they baffle and flaunt you.
There is nothing so trying as a human being and flowers are just like human beings. They are ridiculously dependent when they are young — if they were a jot less so one would leave them to their fate — and they are cantankerous and domineering when they are old. One’s reason tells one to be Greek and let them die, and all the rest of one works to make them last a little longer. If they are crowded together with their family they do not get on at all and make an extremely poor showing. They have to be separated constantly, and one’s only comfort is that they have no orthodox sentimentality about the process. The young ones like frequent moves, the old ones will not be budged, and the young ones invariably want the very corners from which the old ones refuse to move. The big ones bully the little ones. The decadent hybrids produce the rarest colors and pose about doing it. Altogether gardening is a great nuisance, and surely no one would ever do it if she could manage to let the thing alone.
20261102